Chapter 2: American Muslim Converts

The intersectionality of American Muslims converts, while often underappreciated and misunderstood, should be celebrated as a product of American religious freedoms and the internal diversity of the Islamic community.

In this chapter, I will be focusing on American Muslim converts and their role as pioneers who stand at the intersection of culture, religion, and nationality in the United States. Using the story of my convert mother and the story of America’s earliest Muslim converts as a backdrop, I will attempt to underline some significant issues that American Muslim converts deal with on a daily basis because of their individual and collective choices to practice their first amendment rights in a nation that does not always respect them and a religious community that does not always include them. I believe that my mother, a woman who grew up in Camden, New Jersey and who converted to Islam at the age of 18, is a person who perfectly exemplifies the struggle that American Muslims like her face on account of their intersectionality. As historical counterparts for this chapter, I will be diving into the story of Alexander Russel Webb, one of the first documented American Muslim converts who was white and middle-class, as well as other converts who share similar stories. The focus of this chapter will primarily be the ways in which American Muslim converts either lose or gain privileges (and sometimes rights) depending on where they choose to stand on the spectrum of religiosity and nationality.  

For this chapter, I will be relying on the following sources (this remains an evolving list and may be subject to changes):

  • A Muslim in Victorian America: The Life of Alexander Russell Webb by Umar Faruq Abd-Allah Wymann-Land
  • Struggling to Surrender: Some Impressions of an American Convert to Islam by Jeffery Lang
  • The Invisible Muslim: Journeys Through Whiteness and Islam by Medina Tenour Whiteman
  • Pew Research Center’s data on the demographics of American Muslim converts
  • ISPU’s data on American Muslim converts

Acknowledgments

I would like to express special thanks and gratitude to my professor and mentor Dr. Nathan Walker as well as the Rutgers Honors College who have given me the opportunity and encouragement to do this meaningful and pertinent research. By engrossing myself in this subject matter, I honor myself and those who share and have shared with me in the American Muslim experience, such as my friends, family, and religious peers, to whom this research is also dedicated. I would also like to express my appreciation for organizations all around the country such as the ISPU who are committed to educating the public on the realities faced by American Muslims while strengthening interfaith dialogue and exploring new pathways for coexistence and unity.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of ReligionAndPublicLife.org or its partners, funders, or other contributors.

Showcase your Digital Portfolio

Use the Showcases tab on your profile page to publish a digital portfolio. Upload your thesis, publications, speeches, and other assets. Attach a manuscript, embed multimedia, or advertise your projects by adding links to external sources, such as your podcast or book. Your entries will also be displayed in the ReligionAndPublicLife.org Showcase Directory and Mobile App. And make sure to add your Showcase link to your resume so employers can view your professional portfolio.